The Monkey Princess (stellanova) wrote,
The Monkey Princess

  • Mood:

i wonder whereabouts in belfast she's been living for those twelve years?

There have been lots of terrorist comparisons recently - mostly between Al Quaeda and the 'Ra. Now, I grew up believing that Martin McGuinness was basically the antichrist (an opinion that has been but slightly tempered as the years went by). I still slam the door in the faces of Sinn Fein candidates when they call at election times as soon as I see the badge, usually when they're in mid-sentence. I am disgusted by the hypocrisy of a party that claims to be a left-wing one and yet feeds off pure anti-British bigotry to the extent that it honours a Nazi-collaborator purely because he was "against the Brits". And yet this piece in the Grauniad by Lionel Shriver really rubbed me up the wrong way. I agree with her outrage that SF MPs can claim the benefits of their office while not taking their seats. And I agree that people forget pretty quickly what McGuinness et al were (ALLEGEDLY!) responsible for (not my mother, I might add - she refused to talk to him at a DC function a few years ago. You go, principled Moots!). But some of the piece reads as if what happened there happened in some sort of vacuum, a world in which Bloody Sunday didn't happen, in which Catholics weren't gerrymandered out of their votes. Especially this bit:
Having their cake and decrying it too, Sinn Fein has helped to eviscerate the RUC while continuing to whinge about the awful meanies in the police.

There was never any justification for killing or hurting RUC officers - I think that goes without saying. But to write as if there wasn't a pretty serious reason why a huge chunk of the population of Northern Ireland had little trust in the RUC is just plain stupid. And, yeah, bigoted.
Tags: identity politics, raaar
  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded