Luke said yes! Awwww.
Kirk and the rings were funny.
The Judge! My new heroine!
Not so good:
Rory fucking Gilmore. I can't believe I used to like her. Now she and her poncey rich friends send me into a frenzy of loathing. They're such self-satisfied, smug wankers, who think they're absolutely hilarious. I will concede that they are very convincing and realistic portraits of a certain type of person who I certainly encountered in college, but I didn't want to hang around with people like that in college and I certainly don't now. And Rory! INDEPENDENT? How can she say that when she plans to live off her grandparents for a year? How can she say that while standing in the luxury poolhouse in their back garden? Fuck, she's annoying.
Emily and Richard: I can't believe they'd be quite so naive as to believe they can buy a judge.
The whole "ooooh, the townies are shocked that Lorelai proposed!" subplot. I don't like the idea that it's a man's job to propose anyway, and if this is going to be a big deal then....bleah.
Lorelai and Luke weren't exactly love's young dream? Which is crazy, because there's so much chemistry between those two actors, and they can turn it on when they want to. They're both hot. They are hot together. Give them a script worthy of the hotness.