Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

May. 26th, 2006

Catholics all believe exactly the same thing. There are no feminist Catholics. They all accept every single ruling of the Catholic church.

This may be news to some of us who live in a 95% Catholic country and know plenty of practicing Catholics who use contraception, support gay rights, and are pro-choice, But it's news to the Guardian. And if anyone can see anything but ignorance and anti-Catholicism in paragraphs like this:
However, given that her faith is explicitly anti-abortion and anti-contraception and that its very highest level of priesthood is open only to men, is she really the best-placed person in government to speak up for women's rights?

...then I wish they'd explain it. Now, it does seem that Ruth Kelly is not a liberal Catholic - she's in Opus fucking Dei, after all. However, that doesn't meant that liberal feminist Catholics don't exist - indeed, Kelly considers herself a feminist, despite some possibly noxious personal views on sexual and reproductive issues - and Natalie Hanman's piece is seemingly based on the assumption that they don't, that all Catholics are automatically conservative and that therefore they shouldn't be allowed into any position in which human rights are at stake. That there's no need to examine Kelly's personal beliefs because, as a Catholic, she's automatically a pro-life gay-hating wingnut. I may not be a practicing Catholic, but I know that all Catholics don't believe exactly what the Pope tells them, and I can't express how offensive I find this.


May. 26th, 2006 04:44 pm (UTC)
I almost yelled at the computer when I read your first sentence! I used to be Catholic, and I was always pretty liberal.
I gave it up partly over reasons of dogma, but also partly because I figure if you're going to be part of an organized religion you should follow that religion's rules, and I just couldn't, so I kind of get the whole "all real Catholics believe a, b, and c" thing. On the other hand, organized religion is a cultural thing more than a spiritual thing, and if most of your family has been Catholic since the word existed, and come from a country where you're Catholic or you're a foreigner, it's hard to identify yourself as anything else.
Yeah, I guess I still haven't really worked all this "should I be or shouldn't I be" stuff.


fat pony like thunder
The Monkey Princess

Latest Month

July 2009


Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Cindy S.